Archive for the 'Epistemology' Category

Sean Carroll, Epistemologist

By day he’s a physicist at Caltech, but Sean’s posts at Cosmic Variance include some of the clearest and most level-headed discussion of epistemology to be found anywhere (regardless of academic department).
In a recent post, he carefully explains why it is unreasonable, in light of our best physical theories, to believe in telekinesis and other [...]

God In The Stars

I found this comic via Hemant.

That hypothetical situation sure showed what an intellectually dishonest fellow that fictional atheist was! I have no idea whether this comic is trying to make some sort of point, or what that point might be.
The only reason I’m posting this is because I’ve long dreamed of launching an array of [...]

Am I A Racist?

Two excellent posts from Megan McArdle show why it is very difficult for any of us to answer that question with any certainty. (Well, it’s an easy question to answer for people who are openly and proudly racist. For the rest of us who’d like to think the answer is no, it’s a fine little [...]

Pure Math, Applied Math, and A Priori Proofs

Some people think that scientists doing theoretical work can use mathematics to prove things about the real world a priori of any empirical investigation. This is wrong. Allow me to explain.
It is true that the results of pure mathematics do follow from whatever axioms one starts with a priori of any empirical observations. Indeed, empirical [...]

The Pathetically Lame Mainstream Media

In case you weren’t aware, the vast majority of mainstream media sucks. One big problem is sensationalism bias; however, I can almost forgive them for this, since they are at least acting in their own self-interest by reporting the sensational and extraordinary. What’s truly and utterly pathetic is the media’s tendency to just transcribe whatever [...]

This Is Why You Shouldn’t Listen To The Voices

From Physorg.com:
Swiss council workers had to chop down part of a tree to clear a German truck which got stuck in a narrow dead end because of its driver’s blind faith in his onboard navigation system, police said.
The 37 year-old driver, who was looking for the factory where he was due to drop [...]

Comic: Thad Guy

I recently discovered the comic strip Thad Guy, which might be described as a love child of Dinosaur Comics and xkcd. Thad Guy often takes a comically twisted look at substantive philosophical issues. Here’s one of my favorites:

…and that guy’s dangerous-looking goatee really ties the strip together.

Expertise and Moral/Epistemic Culpability

Alonzo Fyfe, the Atheist Ethicist, wrote an excellent article on Epistemic Negligence in Teaching Religion. I have just one quibble.
The article over-emphasizes the epistemic crimes of experts while ignoring those committed by ordinary people (i.e. parents). Fyfe points out that in some cases, non-experts do not deserve the same moral condemnation for making mistakes [...]

Ramsey + Moore = God ?

Juan ComesaƱa of Certain Doubts points out a very short paper which purports to prove that every rational being should believe they are omniscient and infallible (i.e. they have the epistemic powers of a god). The proof is based on the Ramsey test for conditionals (”If p then q” is acceptable to a subject S [...]

Analyzing the Word “Knowledge”: Why Bother?

Philosophers have spent a lot of time and effort trying to determine the necessary and sufficient conditions for a subject, S, to “know” a propostition, p. Once upon a time, the Justified True Belief theory was ascendent. JTB says that S knows p iff (1) p is true, (2) S believes p, and (3) S [...]